Comments on: Rate & Discuss: Day of the Moon /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/ Fri, 06 May 2011 00:37:29 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: JamButty /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10703 JamButty Thu, 05 May 2011 16:54:16 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10703 <a href="#comment-10652" rel="nofollow">@Ruby</a> Moffat has said a while ago that he didn't decide who River was back then and has been hard to come up with who she is because of that. @Ruby

Moffat has said a while ago that he didn’t decide who River was back then and has been hard to come up with who she is because of that.

]]> By: Calli Arcale /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10690 Calli Arcale Wed, 04 May 2011 23:49:25 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10690 That's exactly what I was alluding to, Rassilon, and of course also what Moffatt was alluding to -- he knew that a significant portion of the audience had seen "Silence in the Library", and would know that yes, she actually would die on that day. Very bittersweet. Not *precisely* a classical case of dramatic irony, but close, in that much of the audience already knew just when that moment would come. For a change, we knew more than River. That’s exactly what I was alluding to, Rassilon, and of course also what Moffatt was alluding to — he knew that a significant portion of the audience had seen “Silence in the Library”, and would know that yes, she actually would die on that day. Very bittersweet. Not *precisely* a classical case of dramatic irony, but close, in that much of the audience already knew just when that moment would come. For a change, we knew more than River.

]]> By: Ellen /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10679 Ellen Wed, 04 May 2011 18:20:49 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10679 @TE It just seems odd how a mysterious lady opens a hatch in the door and closes, its quite random but im sure we will find out ;) @TE

It just seems odd how a mysterious lady opens a hatch in the door and closes, its quite random but im sure we will find out ;)

]]> By: Rassilon /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10678 Rassilon Wed, 04 May 2011 16:42:41 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10678 <a href="#comment-10509" rel="nofollow">@Calli Arcale</a> That already happened. He did not know her at all as Professor River Song in Silence in the Library (Series 4 Episode 8). She 'died' in the next episode - Forest of the Dead. Well, The Doctor 'saved' her anyway, in digital form that is. @Calli Arcale That already happened. He did not know her at all as Professor River Song in Silence in the Library (Series 4 Episode 8). She ‘died’ in the next episode – Forest of the Dead. Well, The Doctor ’saved’ her anyway, in digital form that is.

]]> By: Grace /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10673 Grace Wed, 04 May 2011 02:27:32 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10673 The little girl is the nightmare child that never was.... The little girl is the nightmare child that never was….

]]> By: TE /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10664 TE Tue, 03 May 2011 22:08:42 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10664 <a href="#comment-10663" rel="nofollow">@Ellen</a> The mystery will be resolved soon... ;) @Ellen
The mystery will be resolved soon… ;)

]]> By: Ellen /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10663 Ellen Tue, 03 May 2011 21:45:17 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10663 Who was the eye patched lady? I thought at first something happened and that wasn't supposed to be in but it was Oo Who was the eye patched lady? I thought at first something happened and that wasn’t supposed to be in but it was Oo

]]> By: TE /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10662 TE Tue, 03 May 2011 21:36:40 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10662 <a href="#comment-10655" rel="nofollow">@elena</a> Exactly - River drops the bomb that Rory is her father in Day of the Moon, which would obviously suggest that Amy is her mother. @elena
Exactly – River drops the bomb that Rory is her father in Day of the Moon, which would obviously suggest that Amy is her mother.

]]> By: trevor chalkley /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10658 trevor chalkley Tue, 03 May 2011 20:33:57 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10658 <a href="#comment-10656" rel="nofollow">@Patrick</a> it took six months to get from flor to nyc think about it thats why she was dieing no real food and heat for six months that would kill most little kids!!! @Patrick
it took six months to get from flor to nyc think about it thats why she was dieing no real food and heat for six months that would kill most little kids!!!

]]> By: Patrick /2011/04/rate-discuss-day-of-the-moon/comment-page-5/#comment-10656 Patrick Tue, 03 May 2011 19:37:59 +0000 /?p=27625#comment-10656 <a href="#comment-10647" rel="nofollow">@vaguely</a> Cause i posted this comment: "When the girl regenerated it was 6 MONTHS LATER so what happened in them 6 months?" BUT not this quote: "The little girl is obviously Amy and Rory’s with a Time Head." @vaguely
Cause i posted this comment: “When the girl regenerated it was 6 MONTHS LATER so what happened in them 6 months?”

BUT not this quote: “The little girl is obviously Amy and Rory’s with a Time Head.”

]]>