@elena roberts

the doctor said the cyberman who was found in the underhenge was prob a gaurd or sumthin like that and the locals years ago killed it that why he said never under estamate the celts…if u remember da head was above b4 it followed them down…

yeaah good point, but there is something very creepy about amy’s whole life, i mean even the doctor said to amy; ‘doesn’t it worry you that none of your life makes sense… like everything about is like a fairytale because when she wished for someone to help her the doctor suddenly appeared! and i swear she said she lived with her nan and we never got to see her nan/aunt!? also i reckon everything about her child hood is wrong, very wrong and the fact that the doctor did go back at the end of the first episode to see amy when she was waiting, maybe he told her something then and that must of changed time the fact that he had seen her before the original ten years she had to wait?! x @Jay

thats exactly what i thought and it is him that goes in the box it’s intended for him and whoever blew up the tardis obviously wanted the doctor locked away! x yaa never know xx@Jim

@elena roberts

not doubtin anythin else u sayin jst lettin u knw why the first cyberman was there..:D

I reckon its all taking place in the library!
Remember river song is trapped inside it?
Donna totaly believed in her life inside the libray computer? as did the original controller?
mmmmmmm!

Get this…
the doc says ‘Dosnt it worry u that ur life dosnt make sence” and all that, and then he says ‘too many rooms’
If u look, amys house is two levels, so how come when the doc is chained to the heater, and when river enters the second floor, there is another staircase going up?!
….’too many rooms’, not just the one the prizoner zero was in, but their is an entire level!
Also in the ‘Time of Angles’ Father Octavion calls the doctor sir, and then amy goes ‘you never let people call you sir.’ ive watched all the episodes before that and nobody calls the doc sir, and he certainly dosnt not let ppl call him that, and just to back it up…after amy says it, the doc says “Thats interesting”….and then changes subject…

Comment removed.

Watching eleventh hour and when the Doctor goes into the house where Jeff and the old lady lives she says that she knows him and that she has seen him somewhere before. Maybe he does go back to Amy’s village before the eleventh hour but it could from the dolls or Amy’s obsession when she was younger.

amy made a cartoon of the doctor and all the village have had 12yrs of this cartoon thats how she knws him rory did same wen doctor saw him takin pic ov pisoner zero…

@Shaun
@Jay

Yeah but its the Moff, not RTD whos writing this series
Suspect everything

Yes you’re right about the “third floor” of Amy’s house… and the whole plot of “The Lodger” could be tied to that… also before tonight… go back and rewatch Flesh & Blood if you can… particularly the scenes of the Doctor with “blind” Amy in the Forest… and lookout for the “returning Doctor’s tweed jacket” section (believe me I don’t think this is a continuuity blip…) “Remember what I told you when you were 7″…. Piqued your interest yet? Afterall… I think the Moff has grasped that this is a series about… TIME TRAVEL….!

@Steve

They said the raggy doctor..was a cartoon ov the doctor thats how the old lady knws him…

omg yes we knw about the jacket not new news…the thing with the third floor in amys house were the third floor out side look at the house frm the outside no third floor not even a loft window..look back at lodger there was a extra floor inside and out…

Well…looks like we are all wrong
…for now