Amy. In a pirate suit.

Thank you Messrs Moffat and Thomson. Thank you.

Simply AWESOME!!

After two outstanding opening episodes, this crashed back down to Earth. It wasn’t BAD, it was just a bit normal, there wasn’t much to distinguish it. Every series has a few of them, this is the first of this run; let’s hope Gaiman delivers something rather more special and engaging next week.

It’s a six out of ten on this one.

It wasn’t the greatest of episodes but had interesting points mainly at the end with the Doctor doing the pregnancy scan (again), amy remembering what happened on the beach and the re-appearance of the mysterious woman from Day of the Moon did not expect that but wasn’t great but had some ok moments.

I enjoyed this episode after the first two episodes, which were full of action and adventure. This one was just plain normal Doctor Who with little elements of danger and heartbreak as well. A nice little bridge really to relax our minds cause 4,5/6 and 7 look like they are going to be EPIC

7/10 for me

i thought it was brillient but im more interested in the silver eye patch woman madame kovarian i wonder if there going to do another river song type caractor with her that u have to wait and wait to find out who she is

I admit, it wasn’t the best episode ever BUT it did drop massive hints about there being 2 universes, 2 ships, 2 doctors 2 EVERYTHING!!
Maybe even 2 Amy’s?
One pregnant one not and that is why the TARDIS cannot decide which one she is.
Surely the TARDIS will know, or be able to track, if there is another one hanging around out there….

Just a theory, as always

It was a good episode, but it just didn’t catch me like the last two did. The Siren being a doctor was a nice touch though, but it was freaky when she went from blue to red. It really got me watching when Amy started swashbuckling- loved the Doctor’s face! Overall, it was a good episode, maybe the pirate ship could bump into the Titanic one day. I can’t wait for the next episode!

Agree with @Lisa-Marie, think it was a big hint at the possible answer a lot of the mysteries but still a lot unknown. Wasn’t my fave episode ever but next week’s looks great.

episode was good, but not as good as the previous two, the lady amy keeps seeing is very interesting cant wait to see how that turns out, and the pregnancy too. 7/10

does anyone have any idea who the silver eye patch lady is ?

Oh, I really liked it!

Being “average Doctor Who” isn’t a bad thing; in fact it’s just what the series needed at this point. Moff’s great at striking a balance. Maybe a second viewing is needed for some. Then another viewing at the end of the series, to see how it fits in line with everything?

C’mon people: ‘Average’ Doctor Who is brilliant.

Oh, and after mulling over what the Eyepatch Woman said in ep 2… I hope Amy’s not just dreaming all this.

No, no, can’t be; Steven Moffat’s too clever for that.

I think it served its purpose perfectly: A short and simple but also fun Doctor who story.

It took me back to the girl in the fireplace at times(one of my first Who Stories).

@shawn
I think shes Amys midwife. She talks about “keeping calm” and says “Your doing fine”.

@shawn
No-one knows. This is another mystery but some seemed to think it was River Song and it kinda did look like her a little bit. But we’ve no idea. But the eye patch lady is coming back in episode 8 – a character called Madame Kovarian played by Frances Barber who appeared in episode 2 and 3 as eye patch lady.

@The silence
yeah it reminded me of that episode as well. especially the whole 2 worlds thing. like girl in the fireplace episode there was france in the 18th century or something but on the other side some kind of spaceship. i know im not making much sense sorry lol

It was brill just brill and the end was a cliffhanger 5 stars

this episode was good, but not as good as i thought it would be. But at the end of the day what do you expect i mean it’s a pirate ship with pirates with a siren and a ghost you can’t possibly expect more from that. There were a lot of hints dropped throughout, yeah i agree that the eyepatch lady is Amy’s midwife in the future and i believ she is currently pregnant. Im still sticking to my theory that it’s the Doctor who’s the father of the baby. Im actually a bit curious in the next episode that the other ‘time lord out there’ Idris is either the baby/little girl grown up or re-generated, but on the other hand she might actually be the Doctor’s wife that’s what puts me off. I really enjoyed rory in this episode,especially when he said “I want a beard!” and Amy Pond complete with sword classic! I wanted to hear Lily Cole (the siren) speak though it would have made it more eerie it’s not my fave but i really enjoyed it just kinda ****** off we still don’t know if Amy’s pregnant yet haha but hopefully we find out before summer

@The silence
i never thought about that theroy before thanks i thought she was river r something but then thought it cant be